Is "Fidelity-Chastity" Still in Effect? Yes! November 20, 2008 |
Dear Presbyterian Renewal Network Leaders, Some confusion exists about the position of the PC(USA) on sexual standards for ordination. Actions by the General Assembly in 2006 and 2008, and a decision by the General Assembly Permanent Judicial Commission in 2008, have been interpreted differently in different quarters of the denomination. Coalition board member Jim Berkley attended a recent meeting of the Covenant Network and reported in The Layman the public statements he heard at that meeting. James Tony, also a Coalition board member, responded. I think you will benefit from reading why Pastor Tony asserts that the behavior of candidates for ordination and installation must comply with the express standard of G-6.0106b. The article below -- now slightly expanded -- appeared on Presbyweb on November 17 and is posted on the Coalition website as well. I'm reproducing it in this email. For a more complete analysis of the current status of ordination standards, I suggest you read the three articles on AO #22 by James Tony and Gordon Fish. |
Is it now possible to ordain those who do not comply with the "fidelity-chastity" standard? Not according to the General Assembly Permanent Judicial Commission (GA PJC). Jim Berkley reports that at the Covenant Network's recent meeting, Doug Nave ("ubiquitous as counsel arguing for gay ordination in judicial cases") said, "who knows if B [Amendment B, which proposes to substitute ambiguous language for the fidelity-chastity standard] will pass or not. We haven't taken a vote in a long time. But it almost doesn't matter. Whether it happens or not, we have the ability right now to ordain whoever we want to ordain." No, says the GA PJC in Bush, which is exceedingly clear and definitive: Governing bodies are not free to permit exceptions to the explicit requirements of the Constitution. The decision cites the explicit requirements of G-6.0106b. Just read what the GA PJC has actually said. Here is that Authoritative Interpretation (AI) as adopted by the 218th GA: James R. Tony is Senior Pastor of Palos Park Presbyterian Community Church in Chicago Presbytery. |
I hope this work by members of the Coalition's Discipline Team is both encouraging and helpful to you. We hope it gives you confidence as you conduct examinations in your presbytery, and as you vote "No" on the new Amendment B and preserve our current ordination standards.
Yours in Christ, Terry Schlossberg |
The Presbyterian Coalition | 4604 Grove Avenue | | Richmond | VA | 23226